स्वयं के कारणों से पदोन्नति त्यागने के उपरांत उसी पदोन्नति आदेश के आधार पर बाद में पदोन्नति पाने की पात्रता नहीं- माननीय सर्वोच्च न्यायालय का निर्णय दिनांक 10.10.2014 (म.प्र.शासन विरुद्ध रामानन्द पाण्डेय)

Posted on 24 Oct, 2014 10:41 pm

स्वयं के कारणों से पदोन्नति त्यागने के उपरांत उसी पदोन्नति आदेश के आधार पर बाद में पदोन्नति पाने की पात्रता  नहीं- माननीय सर्वोच्च न्यायालय - CIVIL APPEAL NO. 9486 OF 2014 (STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH & ORS. VERSUS RAMANAND PANDEY )  

Court held:

• In 1991 SC 2010 (sic) (Union of India Vs. K.V. Jankiraman), the Apex Court held that the sealed cover procedure can also be reported to only in the event a charge sheet in a disciplinary proceeding and a challan in a criminal case is issued/filed. 
• .In fact, the issue focused and discussed, on the basis of which cancellation order dated November 25, 2006 is passed, itself is extraneous.
• The cancellation did not come because of the reason of pendency of any alleged departmental inquiry against the respondent, which was self created reason given by the respondent. No doubt, it would have been better for the appellants to write to the respondent, before cancelling the order of promotion, stating that since there was no departmental inquiry, he should report at the Sagar Office or even if such a complaint is pending, that is no reason not to join the office in District Sagar.